January 17, 2010

"Say You're Sorry"

Recently Heather wrote a post which generated a lot of discussion on both her blog and on facebook. Here are some highlights I liked:

From her post:

"Please is *not* a magic word. It’s no more a magic word than Abracadabra or A La Peanut Butter Sandwiches......I’m pointing out how ingrained it is, that children are of the lesser value, they must submit, and say the *magic* word or they risk not getting what they want. It’s like asking a dog to sit before giving him a treat. I don’t ask my children to do tricks before I give them a drink, a snack, or a ride to the store......It may sound silly to you but, it’s the danger of making your child’s inner voice your own. My inner voice has only begun to be my own, using my own logic, and my own confidence......I am NOT rejecting the idea of being polite or being gracious. I'm rejecting the idea of forcing children to be that way. I'm rejecting the ideas of "magic words" and "forced manners" only being robotic pleases and thank yous......My rejection is of *forced* manners. Not of "politeness or graciousness"...
~Heather

and from facebook:

"IMO, insincere graciousness can be worse than being rude. Being gracious and/or nice to people is in itself a welcome personality trait but, it's quite different than "always say please and thank you" because *I* said so." ~Heather

************************************************

I happen to be in complete agreement with Heather on this.
I have something to add that I think goes nicely with this topic...

I feel that making a child say they are sorry is equally as likely to confuse their inner voice. Or to make them think that saying sorry, even if they truly aren't, will act as a magic word to erase what they have done.

I have known people (children and adults) who say they are sorry as soon as they are caught doing something that someone views as wrong. It's as if they think it's a "get out of jail free card".

The act of saying sorry should be authentic or it means nothing.

And in an instance when a child is being told that they must say they are sorry, the focus for them often becomes pleasing you, rather than saying it from a place of sincerity.

I believe that words like "please", "thank you", and "I'm sorry" are important when used with authenticity. I use them all often, as do Drew and the kids. And we don't live in a vacuum. We talk about expectations (our own and those of the society we live in) just as we talk about everything else. As Faith said: "I let my kids in on the social culture we live in but without coercion."

I want my children to know their own voices.
I want them to do what is true to them.
I want our relationship to be sincere.

Not too much to ask, right?

4 comments:

Elisha said...

Right on! I have unfortunately known quite a few people who seem to think this way: as soon as they know they've upset you, they say "I'm sorry", and then get upset if they're not instantly forgiven. I can always tell when someone doesn't mean it; I think most people can.

What's really harmful is some of those people never seem to develop the ability to understand that they've actually hurt someone. They just see the other person's anger or pain as an annoyance, and blurt out "sorry" to make that annoyance go away. I see that happen a lot with schooled kids, but also with married couples who are on the rocks. It's frustrating and sad.

Unschoolers Rock the Campground said...

Sometimes I say things without thinking, and then I usually say "Wow, Sorry I said that!"

Heather said...

You're right. I hate hearing that parental command, "say your sorry".

There are too many variables to even think about and no, it isn't a fix all.

Thanks for your post!

Elisha said...

Ack, I just reread my comment here and realized it sounded bad! I meant to say that people will say they're sorry without actually caring to find out why you're upset. They think it's the word that makes things better, not the meaning behind it.

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails